I won’t go into any fun facts or stats on pollinators. You can read about their total value towards the agricultural industry or other things like that elsewhere. What I’m going to focus on here is pesticide use on trees and the impact that has on pollinators. I’ll help you become a more informed about pesticides and their potential to cause serious ecological damage.
Tree care pesticides
Three of the most commonly used pesticides that are toxic to bees are carbaryl, imidicloprid, and permethrin. These are only the most commonly used pesticides that are toxic to bees, there are many others that are toxic to bees although these are the ones used most around here. Pesticides can be sprayed on trees or applied to the soil as systemic pesticides.
These applications can harm bees in many ways. For example, systemic pesticides can be taken up by flowering plants and the pollen and nectar then become toxic. When taken back to the colony, the poisonous pollen and nectar can cause serious issues, including collapse of the entire colony. Other pesticides are known as contact pesticides, because they will kill bees on contact. This is actually the best outcome when it comes to poisoning bees, because at least they don’t bring it back to their colony to poison the other worker bees, larvae, and queen. Even pesticides that are applied at the right time and persist for relatively short periods of time can cause issues. Bees will go to water sources that are contaminated by overspray and be poisoned. Even when they consume non-lethal doses bees can suffer other health effects - from decreased ability to navigate, impaired motor function, decreased memory and ability to learn. All of these can cause a bee to not return home and die.
These chemicals do not only negatively impact bees. Other beneficial organisms - including ladybugs, earthworms, predatory wasps, and many more, are negatively impacted by pesticides. Runoff or overspray from pesticides can also injure to fish and other aquatic life. Many of these chemicals are considered safe to people, and that is why they are used. The interactions of these chemicals and the environment is often not studied because the companies applying and producing these chemicals would rather not have the negative effects caused by their products known. As we now know, the company that produced Roundup stated that it was “as safe as table salt”, all the while knowing that they had evidence of its carcinogenic effects.
Pesticide application
One way to limit the negative impacts of pesticide use is to choose a safe method of application.
Spraying
Spraying pesticides is certainly the most damaging way to control for insects. Many pest control specialists will claim they take all necessary precautions to avoid overspray and impact to non-target plants. But the reality is that it is essentially impossible to avoid these things. Especially in compact Colorado backyards there are always flowering plants and non-target plants within the area that is sprayed. These sprays are typically done from multiple angles to ensure the entire tree is covered, which means that everything under and around the tree will we sprayed. The nature of spraying trees makes it nearly impossible to not impact pollinators with the pesticide.
Soil application
Soil application is far better than spraying, but it can still cause issues. The good thing is that it is much easier to avoid non-target plants when applying pesticide to the soil. The main issue with soil applied systemic pesticides is that they will leach through the soil. If they come into contact with the roots of a plant that attract pollinators it will impact bees and other insects. These soil-applied pesticides not only can injure pollinators, they can also harm soil organisms.
Trunk injection
This method is generally considered the least harmful to not target organisms. This method involves drilling into the tree and injecting the pesticide directly into the trunk. This means that no pesticide ends up anywhere but inside of the tree. Although this is the best option it is important to remember that even this can impact non target organisms because the leaves, flowers, and pollen of these trees will still contain the pesticide.
Deciding to use pesticides
When taking advice from anyone (including me) you can ask yourself two things.
Are their intentions pure, or do they interests in conflict with my best interests? With pesticide application there are three main considerations and each company and person will value them to differing degrees. It’s important to think about how much the tree care professional is considering you, the environment, and personal gain.
If their values and intentions align with yours, then ask - do they have all of the information and knowledge necessary to provide good sound advice? The truth is, every one is going off of incomplete information. Sometimes there aren’t studies regarding certain impacts of some chemicals. Sometimes there is such limited information that the studies can’t be completely trusted. Think about the early COVID days, information was incomplete and often assumptions and conclusions were found to be incorrect. Even when a person or organization’s intentions are pure, the advice and information you get from them may not take everything into consideration and could have serious negative externalities.
I share these concerns to encourage you to be skeptical about information people share, and why they are sharing it. For example, I hear about companies telling people they need to spray pesticides to control Cooley spruce adelgid. But these insects do little damage to the health of the tree, and the decreased growth could actually be a benefit to the long term health of the tree. Despite this fact many plant healthcare techs and sales guys will receive a bonus for the upsell and will push it on their customers. This behavior may not always be malevolent in its intentions, but the end result can be far worse than the problem they solve.
Sometimes the pursuit of personal gain can cause people to do questionable things. The purpose of this article is not to say that all chemicals and pesticides should be avoided, but rather to encourage you to do research, and weigh the pros and cons of choosing when and how to use pesticide treatments.
Feel free to contact me if you are unsure about the pesticides being used around your property and the potential negative consequences. When it comes to pesticides Im always happy to spend a few minutes talking about the possible consequences of their use or misuse.